Immersion Is an Ear Problem
Controlled studies keep finding that spatial audio buys presence more cheaply than the industry assumes. The budget templates still tend not to have a line for it.
In 2022 a team publishing in Frontiers in Signal Processing did something the immersive industry mostly avoids: they varied picture and sound independently and asked which one people felt. Seventeen trained listeners watched the same scenes at three video resolutions (0.5, 1.5 and 2.5 megapixels per eye) under three audio conditions, from mono up to head-tracked binaural with room acoustic rendering.
Adding room acoustics to head-tracked binaural produced the same gain in reported immersion as multiplying the pixel count by five. Full auralisation at 20% video scored 5.79; head-tracked binaural at 100% video scored 5.76: no statistically significant difference, p = 0.891.
This is not a finding that sound beats pictures. Video resolution had its own significant effect on immersion, and a larger effect than audio on audio-visual quality judgements. The authors bound the comparison to what they tested: a headset, headphones, and seventeen trained listeners they suggest retesting on naïve subjects. Reading it across to a loudspeaker-based room is an inference, not their claim; it is a reasonable one, and it should have changed how rooms get costed.
It has not. One widely circulated 2026 cost guide for interactive installations splits a project into hardware at 30 to 50%, software and content at 30 to 50%, and fabrication and installation at 15 to 30%. Audio is not a category. One studio's template is not an industry survey, but the omission will be familiar to anyone who has priced this work: audio sits unnamed inside someone else's percentage, which is how a discipline gets value-engineered out at the second budget review. The same studio's sound guide argues for 5 to 15% of project cost (its own estimate, not a benchmark), which tells you both that practitioners know it matters and that they are arguing for scraps.
What the body does before the visitor decides
The case for sound is not aesthetic. It is physiological, and it is measurable.
A study in Frontiers in Virtual Reality in July 2025 put 68 participants through VR content with and without software spatial audio enhancement (dynamic gain shaping plus HRTF-based localisation) and analysed physiology from 58 of them. In the commercial title tested, self-reported audio quality, auditory involvement and sound localisation all rose significantly; in the second title only involvement did, which is the honest version of the result. The body moved too: facial EMG showed shifted valence, arousal rose significantly toward the end of a scripted helicopter event, and heart rate variability dropped significantly in the enhanced condition during that event's final ten seconds. A separate published dataset (31 participants, 24-channel EEG, wristband blood volume pressure and electrodermal activity) points the same way: earlier work on it reported heart rate variability tracking the involvement dimension of presence specifically.
The practical claim is narrow but strong: audio changes autonomic state, on the timescale of an event rather than a visit. A visitor cannot tell you why a room got tense. Their heart rate can.
Adding room acoustics to head-tracked binaural moved immersion as much as multiplying the pixel count by five. One of those two upgrades is a software decision.
The frontier is control, not volume
Almost none of the current toolset is about being louder.
Sphere Immersive Sound, built on HOLOPLOT's wave field synthesis and 3D audio-beamforming, runs roughly 1,600 permanently installed X1 Matrix Array modules plus 300 mobile ones: 167,000 individually amplified drivers for audiences up to 20,000. What that buys is not level but consistency and address: audio that holds quality across distance, different content sent simultaneously to different sections of the same room, and a whisper that arrives as though the speaker were beside you.
Below that scale, object-based systems are now standard specification. d&b's Soundscape handles up to 128 sound objects across 64 loudspeaker outputs, with an acoustic-emulation module running 144 convolvers and impulse responses up to 6.3 seconds: an artificial room laid over a real one. L-Acoustics' L-ISA Processor II carries 128 inputs and outputs at 96 kHz, and its DJ product uses machine-learning source separation to split a mix into four sources in real time for placement. Meyer's Constellation does the reverse trick electroacoustically, changing a room's apparent acoustics on a preset; Spacemap Go runs 32 inputs across 256 outputs from an iPad. At the other extreme, directional arrays put a narrow beam of audio over one exhibit and leave the next one silent.
The frontier has moved from reproducing sound to controlling where it exists. That is a spatial design problem, which is why it belongs in the room's design phase and not a post-production week.
DATALAND, Refik Anadol's AI arts museum, opened at The Grand LA on 20 June 2026 with 250 L-Acoustics loudspeakers (its Data Pavilion carrying separate bottom, surround and height layers plus twenty-five X6i units for personalised audio). Anadol's framing is the useful one: "Sound is not merely an accompaniment to my visual installations; it is an intrinsic element, co-constituting the overall sensory experience."
The cheapest presence per pound on the drawing
At BCVR this is the argument we have most often, and almost never with the creative team. It is with the budget.
The pattern is predictable. A project is scoped with a strong sonic idea; the projector count rises during technical design; audio absorbs the difference. What gets lost is rarely fidelity (cheap speakers sound fine in a noisy room). It is placement. Once a sound is no longer attached to a specific point in space, the room stops being a place and becomes a screen with a soundtrack. Every mechanism in the research above runs through localisation, and localisation is the first thing a compromised system gives up.
The fixes are unglamorous. Decide where the listener's head will be before choosing loudspeakers: a system for a seated audience and one for people wandering are different systems. Put a number on the room's noise floor at design stage rather than discovering it on site. And give audio its own budget line, because a discipline without a line item funds everyone else's overruns. The return shows up where clients actually measure: dwell, completion, whether people go quiet. Vendor-cited figures putting audio at 30 to 40% of perceived immersion, or good sound adding double digits to dwell, are worth what second-hand citations on a supplier blog are worth; the peer-reviewed physiology is what to take into a client meeting.
Put a line in the budget
None of this argues for spending less on the visual. It argues the ratio is wrong, in a direction that is cheap to fix: room acoustic rendering, object placement and a specified noise floor are mostly design decisions and software, competing against pixels that cost money by the square metre.
If you commission immersive work, ask for the audio design at the same review as the visual, and ask what happens to it when the budget moves. If you build it, price the listening position before the screen. The emotional payload of an immersive room has always been carried by sound. The paperwork should admit it.
Scott Marshall is founder of BCVR (https://www.bcvr.io), a London-based immersive production studio working across XR, projection mapping, spatial audio and digital twins for brand and cultural clients.
Sources
- Frontiers in Signal Processing, "On the Relative Importance of Visual and Spatial Audio Rendering on VR Immersion" (2022)
- Frontiers in Virtual Reality, "'Did you hear that?': Software-based spatial audio enhancements increase self-reported and physiological indices on auditory presence and affect in virtual reality", 31 July 2025
- BMC Research Notes data note, "Data on neurophysiological and psychological responses to audio immersive experience in stereo and 3D audio formats"
- Sphere Entertainment Co., Sphere Immersive Sound powered by HOLOPLOT
- AVNation, 26 June 2026
- Sound & Video Contractor, "Tech Roundup: Electroacoustics and Spatial Audio 2026", 6 June 2026, updated 18 August 2026
- L-Acoustics at ISE 2026 (3 to 6 February 2026, Barcelona)
- Utsubo, "Interactive Installation Cost Guide 2026"
- Utsubo, "Sound Design for Interactive Installations: 2026 Guide"
- Holosonics, "Museums and Galleries"



